| Unofficial The Phantom Stranger Vol. 4 Index |
Credits:
| Plot | Dan DiDio |
| Story | J.M. DeMatteis |
| Pencils | Philip Tan |
| Inks | Jason Paz |
| Colors | Ulises Arreola |
| Lettering | Travis Lanham |
| Associate editing | Harvey Richards |
| Editing | Wil Moss |
| Group editing | Brian Cunningham |
Feature Character(s):
- Phantom Stranger (also in flashback in between ??? and issue #1; assumes the identity of Philip Stark in flashback)
Guest Star(s):
- Justice League Dark
- John Constantine (last in Justice League Dark #18)
- Black Orchid (last in Justice League Dark #18)
- Deadman (last in Justice League Dark #18)
- Frankenstein (last in Justice League Dark #18)
- Madame Xanadu (last in Justice League Dark #18)
- Zatanna (last in Justice League Dark #18)
- Nightmare Nurse (first appearance)
Supporting Character(s):
- Elena Stark (in flashback preceding issue #1)
- Allie Stark (in flashback preceding issue #1)
- Tim Stark (in flashback preceding issue #1)
Villain(s):
- Sin Eater (first appearance; also as Philip Stark in flashback to death)
Location(s):
Comment(s):
- Story continued from the previous issue and continued in the next issue.
- The series continues as Trinity of Sin: The Phantom Stranger.
Solicitation:
- The Phantom Stranger investigates his past and is quickly reminded of the price he must pay for being part of The Trinity of Sin.